There are many tests reported in the literature, commonly including:

  • McMurray’s
  • Apley’s compression
  • Joint line tenderness
  • Thessaly’s
  • End range flexion/extension overpressure

This conclusion must be taken with caution since frequent methodological design flaws exist within the included studies, most studies suffered from various biases, and between-study heterogeneity makes pooled data unreliable.”

We don’t even do the Apley’s compression test. Never saw a value, like the Thessaly Test. Nice in theory but just not good enough when tried in a clinical practice.

Even need to Diagnose Meniscus Tears?

We must accurately diagnose and explain to the patient that many people have meniscal tears in their knee when they have trauma . The recent literature builds a strong case for a very good recovery without surgery. That’s right, surgery is often not needed for many people diagnosed with a meniscus tear.

This  paper really created waves when it was released in 2013. They stated that “outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy were no better than those after a surgical procedure.”

Don’t get me wrong, surgery may be needed, especially for the people sustaining an acute meniscus tear.  But that may only be a small portion of the people presenting to us in the clinic.  

In these people, We reduce the inflammation and restore ROM , strength and see how they do. Maybe a 6 week PT course is all they need, you never know.

The research does not support using these tests to diagnose and may add to the fear avoidance a patient may exhibit after such a diagnosis. This systematic review and meta-analysis in the British Medical Journal stated:

The results of this systematic review indicate that the accuracy of McMurray’s, Apley’s, JLT and Thessaly to diagnose meniscal tears remains poor.


What meniscus tests do do?


To Read More Register Now or Log in

Categoy Details

  • 05 Jun 2018
  • Knee